Challenges faced by smallholder farmers trying to adopt regenerative practices

The Challenges Facing Smallholder Farmers and Nature-Based Solutions

Regarding regenerative practices, it's all about improving agro-ecology conditions enabling productive soils to be more resilient to climate shocks, particularly droughts and floods.Challenges faced by smallholder farmers trying to adopt regenerative practices.

One of the biggest challenges for smallholder farmers, in general – and also regarding adopting regenerative practices – is the cost of farm inputs and the labor required to apply them. As a result, many smallholders tend to under-apply inputs and rely on family versus hired labor. They also tend not to value family labor, or the opportunity cost of their time, leading to inaccurate assessments of the financial viability of their operations. Smallholders also typically do not conduct soil analysis but rather use traditional practices or, conversely, rely on advice provided by representatives of agrochemical input companies. In the case of traditional practices, the application of organic inputs is often too little or too uneven to make any significant impact on crop yields. For example, coffee farmers, who often farm on steep slopes, tend to apply less, relatively heavy and bulky, organic inputs to coffee plants located at greater distances from their farmhouses, particularly uphill ones.

For regenerative practices, smallholder producers typically need to invest more labor as they convert from conventional or traditional farming practices, and they sometimes experience reduced productivity while waiting for the benefits of more resilient practices to develop. Surviving that transitional period is often a significant challenge.


Regarding regenerative practices, it’s all about improving agro-ecology conditions enabling productive soils to be more resilient to climate shocks, particularly droughts and floods.

There is a strong connection between upper watershed management and protection of forest and other habitat to ensure the provision of adequate water for agricultural and household consumption. Planting crops on contours and using vegetative and other barriers also helps to reduce soil erosion and improve aquifer recharge. Similarly, shade management, and ideally the use of cover crops, is critical to help regulate ambient and soil temperature and to balance competition for light, water and nutrients between crops and shade species. The use of cover crops and shade trees can also help to control plant diseases and to improve nutrient cycling, soil organic matter and soil moisture. Such regenerative practices can be used with both natural and synthetic fertilizers, though when these are combined the use of synthetic fertilizers typically declines over time as soil organic matter and biota – and the synergistic relationships between those – increase.

 

Nature for Justice supporting smallholder farmers to promote regenerative practices:

We’re working with a range of producers under varying conditions and circumstances, including in North Carolina in the US through our Farmer Inclusion Program which focuses on Black, Indigenous and People of Color (BIPOC) farmers. I’m focusing my attention on smallholder producers in the tropics, with an emphasis on Latin America, given that I’m based in the region. We see a particular opportunity to work with coffee and cocoa producers to generate nature-based solutions (NbS) to climate change, with an initial focus on coffee in East Africa, though we anticipate also working with coffee and cocoa farmers in other regions in the near future. We also see good potential to increase the use of shade trees in existing and new coffee and cocoa farms, to promote more effective pruning and fertilizer management practices, and to build soil carbon in ways that can both improve farmer livelihoods and generate carbon credits. In some regions, notably in Latin America, there is also good potential to promote these agroforestry systems as alternatives to marginal cattle ranching in areas that were deforested for that purpose, and to develop associated NbS projects.

Our Role:

Our role is quite simple, but not easy: to build the capacity of our partner organizations to work more effectively with the smallholder producers, and in some cases also larger farmers, that they support. In most cases, in addition to promoting regenerative practices, we also seek to help our partners to develop NbS projects, assisting them to interact effectively with relevant financial and technical actors and ensuring that the terms of such projects are transparent and equitable. In addition, depending on the circumstances and our partners’ interests, we’re also interested in supporting our partners to participate in alternatives to carbon offset projects, such as insetting, zero-deforestation or other credible claims being made by agricultural companies about their supply chains and related sourcing footprints/impacts. We’re seeking to improve the economic wellbeing of local communities by promoting more resilient farming and natural resource management, where NbS and payment for ecosystem services can help to support the transition to regenerative practices for smallholders.

Author

  • Frank Hicks

    Frank has over 30 years of broad expertise in international development as a senior manager, board member, and consultant with leading NGOs, foundations, and impact investing funds. He is based in Costa Rica, formerly in West Africa, Asia, and the US.

    View all posts

More to explore

First 30×30: Indigenous Nations Lead the Way

In the United States, small-scale farmers account for 90% of all farms but manage less than 50% of total farmland. This imbalance is becoming more acute as small farmers face mounting challenges: the average age of these farmers exceeds 60, the costs of agricultural inputs continue to rise, and large-scale farms benefit from economies of scale. Compounding these difficulties, small farms are disproportionately affected by extreme weather events, droughts, and changing growing seasons—factors that disrupt crop yields and livestock production. These pressures are driving younger generations away from farming, threatening the backbone of the nation’s agricultural network.

For companies seeking to build resilient, ethical, and climate-smart supply chains, this program offers a scalable and strategic solution. Through partnering with farmers through the program, businesses can ensure a reliable supply of high-quality agricultural products while supporting the long-term viability of smallholder farms.

Read More »
North Carolina Agricultural Fields with a Farmer House

Growing American Farmer Prosperity Program: How we’re Reinventing Supply Chain Resilience through Regenerative Smallholder Farming

In the United States, small-scale farmers account for 90% of all farms but manage less than 50% of total farmland. This imbalance is becoming more acute as small farmers face mounting challenges: the average age of these farmers exceeds 60, the costs of agricultural inputs continue to rise, and large-scale farms benefit from economies of scale. Compounding these difficulties, small farms are disproportionately affected by extreme weather events, droughts, and changing growing seasons—factors that disrupt crop yields and livestock production. These pressures are driving younger generations away from farming, threatening the backbone of the nation’s agricultural network.

For companies seeking to build resilient, ethical, and climate-smart supply chains, this program offers a scalable and strategic solution. Through partnering with farmers through the program, businesses can ensure a reliable supply of high-quality agricultural products while supporting the long-term viability of smallholder farms.

Read More »

Scaling Regenerative Agriculture For BIPOC Farmers

Nature For Justice’s Farmer Inclusion team is passionately committed to advancing regenerative agriculture, a transformative approach that not only fosters healthier soils but also minimizes input costs and enhances the resilience of farming systems against extreme and erratic weather conditions, as well as the broader impacts of climate change. Our strategy is grounded in a comprehensive multi-step approach that emphasizes co-creation and shared risk among farmers. We anticipate that scaling our initiatives will rely heavily on private sector investors recognizing the immense value of our bridge financing model, which effectively reduces both financial and ecological risks while ensuring competitive returns. This model ultimately aims to lessen our dependence on continual philanthropic support.

To date, in North Carolina, we have successfully engaged over 125 farmers who manage more than 7,000 acres dedicated to regenerative agriculture. This milestone has been achieved through the disbursement of over $1 million to these farmers, with an additional $2.5 million forecasted for distribution by 2025. We are also preparing to expand our initiatives into Virginia, with ambitious plans to extend our positive impact throughout the Southeast and Midwest.

Read More »

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *